Case study Consistency: +15 percent

Psychologists conducted an intriguing experiment to understand how subtle cues can influence behavior—particularly in encouraging people to vote. In the study, half of the participants were told they were more likely to vote because researchers had (falsely) identified them as being more politically active. This conclusion was casually shared after asking them about their usual voting patterns. The other half of the participants were asked the same questions but weren’t given any feedback about their likelihood of voting.

The Result?

The group that was told they were “more politically active” saw a 15% higher voter turnout than the group that received no additional information. This outcome highlights a fascinating aspect of human psychology: our brain’s desire for consistency. Once individuals were labeled as politically active, they were more likely to align their behavior with that identity. Voting became not just a task but a reflection of who they believed themselves to be.

Why Does This Work?

This phenomenon is rooted in our inherent need to maintain a sense of self-consistency. When we’re given a positive label—whether it’s being “politically active” or being a “valued customer”—we feel compelled to act in ways that uphold that label. This is why strategies like customer loyalty programs that assign “gold” or “platinum” status are so effective. These programs don’t just reward loyalty; they create an identity. Customers begin to see themselves as elite members and naturally want to maintain that status.

Applying This Insight

The implications of this study are powerful for marketing, behavior change, and engagement strategies. Here’s how you can use this principle to influence behavior:

  1. Assign Positive Labels: Acknowledge customers, clients, or participants with affirmations like “You’re one of our most valued customers” or “You’re part of our exclusive community.” This encourages them to act in ways that align with this identity.
  2. Create Status Levels: Use loyalty programs or membership tiers that reinforce a sense of achievement. Terms like “VIP,” “gold,” or “platinum” make people feel special and motivated to maintain their standing.
  3. Encourage Self-Reflection: Ask individuals to describe their behavior or preferences. For example, “How often do you prioritize sustainability when shopping?” This subtle nudge can lead them to align their actions with their answers.

The Takeaway

The study demonstrates how powerful identity and consistency can be in driving behavior. By labeling individuals positively and giving them a role to live up to, you can create meaningful, lasting engagement. Whether it’s increasing voter turnout, fostering brand loyalty, or encouraging healthier habits, this psychological principle is a valuable tool for shaping actions and outcomes.

(Source: www.helpscout.net)

Scroll to Top